Truputi realybės visiems dronistams ir netradicinių kariavimo būdų entuziastams.
Kriegsforscher
In the nearest future I will publish a short thread about the biggest Russian advance near Tonenke, Avdiivka area, where they used a tank battalion in charge. But right now I would like to say a couple of words about FPV drones and the dillusional reality they have created.
First of all, a short remark: I am totally supportive of FPV drones. With both of my hands. But U need understand some thing: that’s not a panacea. Not at all.
U see only successful hits on Twitter or TG channels and they create a wrong point of thinking. Unfortunately, we use so much FPV drones because of lack of ammo for mortars, ATGMs, artillery and even antitank mines.
IMHO, every army needs to has them. They are cheap and very effective, FIRST OF ALL, against the enemy logistics. That’s out of the question and they are really needed.
But here, in your TV war, you mostly see, especially right now, how the enemy columns charge so let’s talk a little bit about this.
1) they wouldn’t even be able to reach our positions if we had enough antitank mines. Same with artillery;
2) they wouldn’t be able to reach the city of Krasnogorivka, that’s the best example right now, if we had enough ATGMs. But they did.
We have at that direction FPV drones. But they cannot change the fact that RUAF AFV are driving there like at home.
And finally , that the biggest charge near Tonenke was stopped with the help of ATGMs and artillery. And well trained and motivated infantry. Not with the help of FPV drones. They just finished the job (mostly damaged and abandoned AFVs).
FPV drones are not the key. And not the panacea. IMHO, the key is:
1) enough artillery shells;
2) well trained infantry;
3) mobility of your forces (AFV). That’s at least.
I am sorry, I am just fucking tired of what I see and when I have phone calls with possible recruits everyone asks me about FPV drones because they see the war via TG channels.
Kriegsforscher
In the nearest future I will publish a short thread about the biggest Russian advance near Tonenke, Avdiivka area, where they used a tank battalion in charge. But right now I would like to say a couple of words about FPV drones and the dillusional reality they have created.
First of all, a short remark: I am totally supportive of FPV drones. With both of my hands. But U need understand some thing: that’s not a panacea. Not at all.
U see only successful hits on Twitter or TG channels and they create a wrong point of thinking. Unfortunately, we use so much FPV drones because of lack of ammo for mortars, ATGMs, artillery and even antitank mines.
IMHO, every army needs to has them. They are cheap and very effective, FIRST OF ALL, against the enemy logistics. That’s out of the question and they are really needed.
But here, in your TV war, you mostly see, especially right now, how the enemy columns charge so let’s talk a little bit about this.
1) they wouldn’t even be able to reach our positions if we had enough antitank mines. Same with artillery;
2) they wouldn’t be able to reach the city of Krasnogorivka, that’s the best example right now, if we had enough ATGMs. But they did.
We have at that direction FPV drones. But they cannot change the fact that RUAF AFV are driving there like at home.
And finally , that the biggest charge near Tonenke was stopped with the help of ATGMs and artillery. And well trained and motivated infantry. Not with the help of FPV drones. They just finished the job (mostly damaged and abandoned AFVs).
FPV drones are not the key. And not the panacea. IMHO, the key is:
1) enough artillery shells;
2) well trained infantry;
3) mobility of your forces (AFV). That’s at least.
I am sorry, I am just fucking tired of what I see and when I have phone calls with possible recruits everyone asks me about FPV drones because they see the war via TG channels.
Comment